Battery Pack State of Health and End-of-Life Criteria: What to Specify for Warranty and Service

State of health (SOH) is a ratio that compares a battery pack’s present capability with a defined reference – most commonly its measured capacity now divided by its rated or beginning-of-life capacity, expressed as a percentage. It is only meaningful when the measurement conditions, the reference value and the end-of-life threshold are fixed in writing. Specify the definition, the discharge rate and temperature used to measure capacity, the reference capacity it is compared against, the end-of-life (EOL) percentage that triggers warranty or service action, and who measures it. Without those, two parties can quote the same “SOH” for the same pack and mean different things. This article sets out how to define SOH, how it differs from state of charge, how EOL is agreed, and the evidence a warranty or service decision should rest on.

SOH is a health indicator, not a directly measured physical quantity. Peer-reviewed reviews of the field describe several families of health indicators and estimation models – from capacity- and resistance-based measures to data-driven methods – and note that each depends on how the measurement is made. A review of health indicators, models and machine learning for SOH estimation sets out that landscape, while a review of SOC, SOH and remaining-useful-life estimation techniques shows where SOH sits alongside the other quantities a BMS reports. For a buyer, the practical consequence is that a BMS-reported SOH figure is an estimate from a defined method, not a laboratory capacity measurement, and the method belongs in the specification.

Rows of cell charge and discharge test cabinets with monitoring computers in a battery test laboratory
Capacity measured on discharge-test equipment is the reference behind a capacity-based SOH definition. Illustrative equipment photo; not a specific test result.

SOH is not state of charge

State of charge (SOC) is how much charge is in the pack right now, as a percentage of its present usable capacity. SOH is how much of the original capability remains. A pack at 100 percent SOC can be at 78 percent SOH; it is full, but full of less. Confusing the two is the most common source of warranty disputes, because a device that “charges to 100 percent” may still deliver far less runtime than it did when new. Our BMS state-of-charge accuracy article covers how SOC error is specified and verified; SOH is a separate number with its own reference and conditions.

The distinction also explains why a fuel gauge cannot be the whole SOH story. SOC is estimated continuously during use from coulomb counting, voltage and model corrections; SOH is a slower-moving quantity that describes capacity fade and resistance growth over the pack’s life. A BMS may estimate SOH from the same signals, but the estimate needs a reference capacity and a defined measurement or learning condition to be comparable over time.

Fix the definition before the number

Three definitions are in common use, and they do not give the same result. Whichever is chosen, write it into the specification with the reference capacity, the measurement conditions and the accepted method. The table is a selection framework; the percentages shown are illustrative examples of how a threshold might be stated, not recommended or standard-mandated values.

SOH definitionWhat is comparedHow it is obtainedWhere it misleads
Capacity-based SOHMeasured usable capacity now / rated or beginning-of-life capacityA controlled full charge and discharge at a defined rate and temperatureDepends strongly on discharge rate, temperature and cut-off voltage; a partial cycle gives a different number
Resistance / power-based SOHPresent internal resistance or power capability vs a baselineDC internal resistance or pulse power test at a defined state of charge and temperatureResistance rises with aging but is temperature- and SOC-sensitive; it tracks power fade, not runtime
BMS-estimated SOHModel output from voltage, current, temperature and cycle historyFirmware algorithm, updated over the pack’s service lifeResult depends on firmware revision and learned parameters; needs a defined reference and update condition

For most OEM warranty and service decisions, capacity-based SOH is the defensible choice because it maps directly onto the runtime the customer experiences, and because IEC 61960-3:2017 provides the framework of performance tests, designations and markings for secondary lithium cells and batteries for portable applications against which a capacity measurement can be defined. The same conditions – discharge rate, temperature, end-of-discharge voltage and charge procedure – must be used for the reference measurement at the start of life and for every later check, or the comparison is invalid.

Specify the measurement conditions as a set

A capacity-based SOH value is a comparison between two measurements, so the conditions of both must be identical and documented. The table lists the conditions to fix; the values are illustrative example figures to be replaced with the conditions agreed for your cell and pack, not recommendations. Avoid writing “capacity at room temperature” when the number will decide a warranty claim.

Condition to specifyWhy it changes SOHExample of a stated condition (illustrative)
Test temperatureAvailable capacity falls at low temperature and high temperature affects aging25 degrees C, with the allowed tolerance stated and the pack soaked to equilibrium
Charge procedure before the testFull-charge detection and termination affect the starting pointFull charge per the approved charging specification, then a defined rest period
Discharge rateDelivered capacity depends on C-rateConstant-current rate equal to the value used for the beginning-of-life reference
End-of-discharge voltageDefines where capacity counting stops, including BMS cut-off behaviourPack-level cut-off voltage per the approved cell datasheet, measured under load
Reference capacityThe denominator of the SOH ratioBeginning-of-life measured capacity of the same unit, or the rated capacity, stated explicitly
BMS firmware and learned stateEstimated SOH changes with firmware and learned parametersFirmware revision recorded with the reading; estimation method named
Pack vs cell levelCell-to-cell variation changes the pack-level resultState whether SOH is measured at pack terminals or estimated from cell groups

Pack-level SOH has an extra complication that a cell datasheet does not show. In a pack with parallel-connected cells and series groups, cell-to-cell variation in capacity and resistance means the weakest group limits the pack, and the pack-level figure can differ from the average of its cells. A published dataset characterising battery modules with parallel-connected cells across diverse module-level states of health documents exactly this kind of module-level and cell-to-cell variation. For a buyer, it is a reason to measure SOH at the pack terminals under the agreed conditions and to keep cell-group balance data from the BMS as supporting evidence, rather than inferring pack health from a single cell or a nameplate value.

Programmable high and low temperature test chamber with a control display used for battery environmental testing
Temperature-controlled testing is part of a fixed SOH measurement condition set. Illustrative equipment photo; not a specific test result.

Agree the end-of-life threshold as a contract term

There is no single EOL percentage mandated across applications. In practice the threshold is a commercial and engineering agreement: the capacity retention at which the pack no longer meets the device’s required runtime, and at which a warranty, replacement or derating action begins. It should be derived from the sizing budget – the runtime the device needs at the worst-case temperature and load – not copied from an unrelated product. Our cycle-life claim verification guide explains how to read and test the retention claims a supplier puts in a datasheet, and the two belong together: the cycle-life claim describes expected fade, and the EOL threshold defines the point at which that fade becomes a contractual event.

Write the EOL clause with four parts: the SOH definition and measurement conditions above; the threshold value and the runtime requirement it protects; who performs the measurement and with what equipment; and what happens when the threshold is crossed. For packs placed on the EU market, SOH data also has a regulatory dimension – Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 introduces an electronic battery passport for the categories in scope, and our EU regulation documentation article maps those requirements, including state-of-health data access, to the records a buyer should request. That access requirement does not define your warranty threshold; it defines the data that must be available.

Build the warranty evidence set

A warranty decision is only as good as the records behind it. The table is the evidence set to specify in the supply agreement; it is a checklist, not a standard-mandated document list.

RecordWhat it establishesWhat to check before accepting it
Beginning-of-life capacity report per model or lotThe reference capacity the SOH ratio is measured againstTest conditions match those used for later measurements; report names the production cell model
Incoming inspection capacity sampleA baseline for the delivered batchSample basis, measurement conditions and results retained at serial or lot level, consistent with the receiving plan
BMS SOH and cycle-history logEstimated health and usage between physical measurementsFirmware revision recorded; data points and update frequency defined
Periodic or on-demand capacity verificationA measured SOH value for a service or warranty decisionSame conditions as the reference; instrument calibration current
Independent laboratory report for a disputed claimA neutral measurement when buyer and supplier disagreeLaboratory accreditation appropriate to the method, under ILAC mutual-recognition arrangements; report states the exact test conditions
Corrective-action and disposition recordHow a pack below threshold is handled and the claim closedThreshold applied, decision, and any replacement or derating recorded against the pack serial

The common failure is a dispute where the buyer measured capacity at one rate and temperature and the supplier points to a datasheet value measured at another. Fixing the conditions at the start, keeping the beginning-of-life reference, and using an accredited laboratory for contested cases is what turns an SOH number into evidence both sides accept.

What to do now

Before the next supply agreement, write one page that defines SOH, fixes its measurement conditions, names the reference capacity, sets the EOL threshold from the runtime budget, and lists the evidence set above. Ask a prospective supplier which SOH definition and firmware revision its BMS reports, and how a capacity verification is performed. For smart packs, review our custom smart battery pack with BMS options, or contact our engineering team with your runtime requirement and warranty target.

Common questions

Is a BMS-reported SOH enough for a warranty decision?

Rarely on its own. A BMS SOH value is an estimate tied to a firmware revision and learned parameters. For a contested decision, define it as supporting evidence and require a capacity measurement under the agreed conditions, with firmware revision recorded alongside the reading.

What end-of-life percentage should we use?

Derive it from the runtime the device must still deliver at end of warranty life, in the worst-case temperature and load, then confirm it against the supplier’s cycle-life claim. Treat it as a contract term, not a number borrowed from another application; the sizing calculation is where the value comes from.

Why does a full charge not mean a healthy pack?

Because SOC and SOH describe different things. A pack can reach 100 percent SOC while its usable capacity has faded well below its beginning-of-life value, so it charges fully but runs for less time. Check SOC accuracy and SOH as separate requirements.

Share the Post:

Related Posts