Passive vs Active Cell Balancing: What to Specify in a Custom Battery Pack

Passive balancing is the right default for most custom packs: it bleeds excess charge from the highest cells through resistors, it costs little, and it keeps every cell at a similar state of charge over the pack’s life. Active balancing earns its cost only where the workload justifies it – high series counts, sustained partial-state-of-charge duty, fast charge or long service lives – because it redistributes charge between cells instead of burning it off, raising the usable capacity of the whole string. The difference in outcomes comes less from the topology itself than from what is written into the BMS requirement: balancing current, thresholds, timing and the bench tests that confirm all three. This article walks through how each method works, when each is the correct choice, and the specification and verification steps that decide whether balancing actually does its job in your pack.

Protection circuit board with balance wiring connected to small lithium battery packs
Protection and balancing circuitry with cell taps: the hardware that carries out whichever balancing strategy the requirement specifies.

Why packs need balancing at all

No two cells are identical. Manufacturing spread, temperature gradients across the pack and different self-discharge rates pull individual cell states of charge apart over months of use. In a series string the consequences are structural, not cosmetic: the peer-reviewed literature states plainly that if cells are not properly balanced, the weakest cell always limits the usable capacity of the battery pack, and that balancing efficiency and slow state-of-charge convergence remain the key open issues in balancing methods. Another study puts it the same way from the power side: without equalisation, a string’s power delivery and usable capacity are restricted by the worst cell in it.

Balancing is also a safety-adjacent function. Both passive and active approaches exist to keep each cell inside its charge window – preventing overcharge at the top and deep discharge at the bottom – which is why balancing behaviour belongs in the pack’s safety file alongside protection trips. The pack-level safety requirements a BMS supports for industrial equipment are set out in IEC 62619, and the balancing function is one of the mechanisms that keeps a pack inside that envelope over time.

What passive balancing does

Passive balancing is the simple case: when a cell’s voltage or state of charge rises above the threshold, the BMS connects a bleed resistor across that cell and dissipates the excess charge as heat. Every cell in the stack ends up at a similar state of charge because the highest ones are drained down rather than the lowest ones filled up. The trade-off is stated clearly in Analog Devices’ application article on active battery cell balancing: passive balancing equalises state of charge but does not extend system run time, and the energy it removes from the strong cells is lost as heat.

That heat is small in most duty cycles – balancing current is typically a fraction of a charge current – but it is not zero, and it lands inside the pack enclosure. In a sealed industrial pack the thermal budget has to absorb it, which is one more reason the balancing current belongs in the written requirement rather than in the BMS vendor’s defaults. For the majority of packs we build – moderate series counts, charging from empty most cycles, well-matched cells – passive balancing converges adequately and the cost is justified by the duty.

What active balancing adds

Active balancing moves charge instead of dissipating it. Energy is transferred from the higher cells to the lower ones – or between neighbouring cells, or between halves of the string – through switched inductors, capacitors or a transformer. The same Analog Devices article summarises the payoff: redistributing charge during charge and discharge increases the total usable charge in the stack, decreases charge time compared with passive balancing, and decreases the heat generated while balancing. In a pack that lives at partial state of charge (a warehouse robot that top-ups between trips, for example), passive balancing has almost nothing to bleed on a full charge, while an active system can keep levelling the string continuously during use.

The implementation menu matters when comparing supplier claims. Inductor-based circuits with reduced switch counts, bidirectional flyback converters that move charge across several cells at once, and switched-capacitor ladders are all established approaches. A 2024 study on inductor-based balancing circuits places balancing at the centre of pack longevity among BMS functions, which is why the topology decision is worth the engineering time. The costs are equally real: more components, more board area, higher quiescent draw, and more firmware states to verify.

AspectPassive balancingActive balancing
MechanismBleed resistor dissipates excess charge from high cellsCharge is redistributed between cells via inductor, capacitor or transformer stages
Effect on run timeNone – equalises state of charge but does not extend itIncreases usable charge in the stack, so it can extend run time
HeatEnergy removed from cells is lost as heat inside the packLess heat generated while balancing; transfer losses depend on topology
Charge timeUnchanged, or slightly lengthened by bleed currentsDecreased compared with passive balancing
Partial-state-of-charge dutyWeak fit – little excess to bleed until full chargeStrong fit – can level the string during charge and discharge
Cost and complexityLow; a switch and resistor per cell tapHigher; power stages, more firmware states, more verification
Typical fitPacks charged from empty regularly, moderate series counts, well-matched cellsHigh series counts, fast charge, PSOC duty, long service life, second-life reuse

One practical nuance from the same Analog Devices article applies to both topologies: their worked example treats full capacity as 90% state of charge precisely because holding cells at or near 100% for long periods degrades lifetime faster, and treats 30% as fully discharged to prevent deep discharge. The balancing thresholds you specify interact with that operating window – balancing strategy and SOC operating range are one design decision, not two.

The parameters that decide the outcome

Whichever topology is selected, the BMS requirement should pin down the same short list of parameters. Leaving them to the supplier’s defaults is how packs end up with balancing that engages too late, runs too slowly to matter, or drains cells the host never sees.

ParameterWhat to specifyFailure mode it prevents
Balancing currentCurrent per cell tap, with the cell count it applies to, and the thermal conditions it is rated atBalancing too slow to correct real-world divergence between charges
Start and stop thresholdsThe voltage or SOC difference that starts balancing and the hysteresis that stops itOscillating or never-triggering balancing; drift below the start threshold forever
Operating windowWhether balancing runs during charge, discharge, rest, or a combinationPSOC-duty packs with balancing that only ever runs at full charge
Reference signalVoltage-based, SOC-based, or a combined algorithm – and who owns the SOC estimateBalancing decisions made off an SOC estimate with known drift
Thermal conditionsCell temperature limits for balancing to be allowed, and behaviour outside themBleeding heat into a pack that is already at its temperature limit
Fault behaviourWhat the BMS reports if a balancing switch fails short or openA failed bleed resistor silently draining one cell for months

Newer research is moving balancing decisions off raw voltage alone – one published method derives cell imbalance from estimated charging and discharging state of power, itself computed from estimated SOC and SOH, rather than from instantaneous cell voltage. If a supplier proposes an algorithm like that, ask how it degrades when the SOC estimate is wrong: the balancing output is only as trustworthy as the estimate feeding it. Our article on BMS state of charge accuracy covers how to verify that estimate before trusting anything built on top of it.

Verifying balancing on the bench

Balancing is easy to specify and hard to see working, so the acceptance plan needs its own steps. The goal is to observe the BMS making correct decisions under a controlled imbalance – not just to confirm that a balancing flag toggles.

StepMethodWhat confirms it passed
1. Create a controlled imbalanceCharge one cell or module above its neighbours (or discharge one below), inside safe limitsDocumented initial imbalance, recorded per cell
2. Observe engagementRun the pack through the specified charge or duty cycle and log cell voltages plus the balancing stateBalancing starts at the specified threshold, on the correct cells, at the specified time
3. Measure the currentMeasure per-cell balancing current in or out during balancingCurrent matches the specification within tolerance, at the specified cell temperature
4. Check convergenceTrack the spread across cells over consecutive cyclesSpread decreases at the expected rate and balancing stops at the specified stop condition
5. Thermal checkRecord pack and board temperature during balancing at the specified ambientNo thermal limit approached; enclosure thermal budget respected
6. Fault injectionSimulate a stuck balancing switch or open tap where the design allowsThe specified fault flag and safe behaviour occur

Steps 2 and 4 are where passive and active differ in practice: passive convergence is slow by nature, so the acceptance criterion should be expressed as spread-over-cycles rather than a single-session correction. For active topologies, add a transfer-efficiency check – energy moved out of a high cell versus energy measured into the low cell – since that ratio is the entire argument for paying the complexity premium.

Where the choice usually lands

For most OEM packs – industrial devices, medical carts, inspection robots charged from empty overnight – passive balancing with a properly specified current and thresholds is the economical and adequate answer. Active balancing becomes the correct choice when the duty genuinely needs it: strings long enough that a single weak cell strands meaningful capacity, PSOC operation, fast charge, or designs that must extract the last percentage of usable capacity for years. The decision is an architecture one, and it belongs in the pack requirement before the BMS is quoted; our overview of the battery management system shows where balancing sits among the other BMS functions, and the cell consistency article explains the upstream manufacturing controls that reduce the imbalance a balancer has to correct in the first place.

If you are weighing passive against active for a new pack and want the balancing parameters and bench plan reviewed before the BMS is frozen, talk to our engineering team about a smart pack with BMS – or send us your requirement and we will respond with the matching balancing specification.

Share the Post:

Related Posts